Skip to content
Back to The Brief

The Brief

Issue 17 · 12 November 2026

The signature is not enough. The person who signs has to check.

A German federal court treats an unchecked AI filing as not made by the lawyer. England's Law Society and Civil Justice Council set out who answers for AI-assisted work. A US appeals court takes a case from a judge over an order with fabricated content. Australia's Fair Work Commission now requires parties to disclose AI use, check what it produced and say so in the document. And the first harmonised EU standard for AI quality management is published.

Europe

Germany: a filing the lawyer did not check is not the lawyer's filing

Germany's Federal Labour Court dismissed an appeal as inadmissible, in a decision on a case from a regional labour court (2 AZN 339/26), and the reason it gave is the one to remember. A filing counts as made by the lawyer, the Senate held, only if the lawyer at least reviews it independently and takes full responsibility for it. What counts is the review, not the signature.

The brief in question was signed and sent through the lawyer's electronic mailbox without being checked. Several of the decisions it cited were largely non-existent or had the wrong content attributed to them. The court said a conscientious review by the lawyer would in any event have noticed and corrected those false citations. A later statement from the lawyer did not cure the problem, and it came after the deadline.

This turns the advice to verify AI output into a procedural result: the filing was treated as not made by counsel at all. The court did not sanction the lawyer, and it does not name the parties. The point is narrower and harder to escape. The person who signs is the person who must have checked.

Why InferisInferis answers from your documents cite the passage they came from, so checking a citation is a click rather than a search.

Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht), 2 AZN 339/26

United Kingdom

England and Wales: the Law Society says responsibility cannot be handed to a tool

On 21 October the Law Society of England and Wales published a 58-page practice note on how solicitors' existing professional and regulatory duties apply when AI is used in legal practice. It covers legal research, document review and disclosure, drafting, client communications and early case assessment.

Its central line, carried by the Society's president Brett Dixon, is that professional responsibility cannot be transferred to an AI system. Solicitors answer for AI-assisted work to clients, the court and third parties, whichever tool produced it. They must review AI-generated material and check citations before anything leaves the firm, and should give clients appropriate information about how AI is used in their matters. Firms can ask clients to disclose their own AI use in turn.

One more point is easy to miss: the note warns that relying on AI should not stop trainees and junior solicitors from developing the core skills the profession needs.

Why InferisInferis can record every AI query in a tamper-evident audit log, so the person who signs off has a record of what was asked and what came back.

The Law Society (England and Wales)

England: witnesses of fact would declare they did not use AI on their statements

The Civil Justice Council, chaired by Sir Geoffrey Vos, published its Final Report on the Use of AI for the Preparation of Court Documents on 29 October. It closes out the working group chaired by Sir Colin Birss, which followed a February interim report and a consultation that ended in April.

The Council draws a line between lawyers' own filings and witness evidence. Statements of case and skeleton arguments get no new AI declaration, because legal representatives already carry responsibility under their existing duties for what they file, and the report does not recommend requiring them to disclose which AI tools they used. For trial witness statements it recommends amending the Civil Procedure Rules so that a witness of fact must declare that their statement was not prepared using an AI tool that generated or influenced its substantive content, including by altering, embellishing, diluting or rephrasing their own evidence.

None of this is a rule yet: the recommendations still need separate action by the Civil Procedure Rule Committee before they take effect. The Council also flagged AI use by litigants in person as outside its remit but needing urgent attention from that Committee.

Civil Justice Council (Courts and Tribunals Judiciary)

North America

United States: a judge loses a case over an order his own chambers produced

In Jackson Federation of Teachers v Fitch (No. 25-60496), a unanimous Fifth Circuit panel vacated a preliminary injunction against Mississippi's anti-DEI education law, House Bill 1193, and ordered the case reassigned away from U.S. District Judge Henry Wingate. The panel found that a July 2025 temporary restraining order from his chambers named plaintiffs who were not party to the case, cited declarations from people absent from the record, and misquoted the statute it purported to apply.

The judge has said a law clerk used an AI research tool on an early draft that was filed by mistake before the chambers' normal review was complete. The panel found that the corrected order which replaced the restraining order, and was later folded into the preliminary injunction, still cited a fabricated 1974 Fourth Circuit case, and described the district court's work as careless and built on falsehoods.

The ruling did not decide whether the law is constitutional and did not sanction the judge personally. The case goes back to a different district judge on remand.

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

Asia-Pacific

Australia: a tribunal writes the check into its own procedure

From 20 October the Fair Work Commission's generative AI requirements apply in all Commission cases. The Commission released the guidance note behind them in August. If you use generative AI to create, write, edit or otherwise prepare a document, you must tell the Commission that you used it and explain how, check the document yourself to make sure everything in it is accurate, relevant and supported by real evidence and legal authorities, and state in the document that you have completed those checks.

Two further duties sit on top. For witness statements and declarations, the witness or declarant must also make sure the document is based on their own knowledge, reflects their own words and is true to the best of their knowledge. Legal practitioners and other professional representatives must include hyperlinks to any case law mentioned in documents prepared using generative AI. Some Commission forms now carry a question about generative AI use; where a form does not have one, or the document is not a form, the Commission asks for a note at the start saying what the tool was asked to do.

The Commission sets out what not complying can cost: documents given less weight or disregarded, an order to pay the other parties' costs as well as your own, or the application or case dismissed. The same guidance tells people not to enter personal information about themselves or others, or confidential case information, into public generative AI tools. The requirements came into force twenty days after a German court held that a filing the lawyer did not review is not the lawyer's filing, and the guidance note behind them predates that decision.

Fair Work Commission (Australia)

Europe

Also this month

  • The first harmonised standard for the EU AI Act is published. EN 18286:2026, a quality management system standard from CEN and CENELEC, gives providers of high-risk AI systems a presumption of conformity with the Article 17 requirements it covers. It applies to providers, not to firms that use such systems, and it is built to sit on top of ISO/IEC 42001 or ISO 9001. More harmonised standards are expected.

    European Commission

Our read

Five items this fortnight, one line running through them. A German court has said what the line means in procedure: a filing the lawyer did not review is not the lawyer's filing, whatever carries the signature. The Law Society has put the same duty in a practice note, with citation checks before anything leaves the firm. England's Civil Justice Council would make witnesses declare the same thing from their side. A US appeals court has shown what the missing check costs once it reaches the docket. And an Australian tribunal now asks you to write on the document that you did the check. Responsibility stays with the named person, and the check comes first.

Get the next issue in your inbox

The brief

AI regulation news for practitioners.

What is changing in AI regulation and enforcement, and what it means for your work with customers and deadlines.